Despite Serious Challenges, PM Suga Makes Way Toward Lower House Snap Election

Satohiro Akimoto
May 3, 2021

Prime Minister Suga at a press conference on April 23, 2021. (Official Website of the Prime Minister of Japan and His Cabinet)

Satohiro Akimoto, Chairman and President of Sasakawa Peace Foundation USA

Prime Minister Suga had a summit meeting with President Biden on April 16, the first foreign leader to visit the president at the White House. This summit not only presented a symbolic confirmation of the U.S.-Japan alliance to the world, but it also included a strong substantive meeting that covered a wide range of issues, including a discussion on geopolitical issues centering on China. Two new initiatives, namely, the Competitiveness and Resilience (CoRe) Partnership and the U.S.-Japan Climate Partnership, which were announced following the summit, identify many ambitious agendas for the United States and Japan to collaborate on, such as technology and innovation, COVID-19 response and global health, climate change and green growth, Paris Agreement implementation, clean energy technology, and support for other countries in decarbonization.

The summit with President Biden is also a critical part of Prime Minister Suga’s domestic political maneuvering to be re-elected party president in September to continue to lead the nation. Prime Minister Suga’s gauging of the timing of a Lower House election, which needs to take place before the term ends on October 21 for the chambers’ current members, is crucially important to solidify his standing within the LDP to be re-elected as party president. Prime Minister Suga would prefer avoiding a presidential party election before the Lower House election to ensure there will be no open rebellion within the party. This is particularly important after failing to win all three national-level elections, a Lower House by-election in Hokkaido, an Upper House by-election in Nagano, and a re-held Upper House election in Hiroshima on April 25.

The successful summit with President Biden is proof that Prime Minister Suga, as the national leader, can manage the relationship with the United States, the most important ally in Japan’s national defense and stability in the Indo-Pacific region. The management of U.S-Japan relations is particularly important for Prime Minister Suga, as foreign policy and security have not been regarded as his forte, as was the case for his predecessor, former Prime Minister Shinzo Abe. After all, no Japanese prime minister survives without having a good strategic relationship with the United States, as was tragically demonstrated by two former DPJ prime ministers, Yukio Hatoyama and Naoto Kan.

Looking ahead, the best scenario for Prime Minister Suga is to, 1) manage to hold the Tokyo Olympics and Paralympics per schedule this summer, 2) expand vaccine rollout to suppress new cases from exploding, 3) hold a snap election to solidify his re-election standing for presidency within the party, and 4) hold an election for party president to continue as prime minister. However, each step has uncertainties within itself: 1) the effects of COVID-19 and its variants on an international sporting event is unclear, 2) whether or not vaccine rollout can be sped up to suppress the rise in new COVID-19 cases, 3) whether or not Prime Minister Suga can manage to have a reasonably respectable victory in the general election together with coalition partner Komeito, and 4) if a delicate balance can be maintained among the three legs that support Prime Minister Suga, i.e., Hosoda (Abe) faction/Aso faction/Takeshita faction team, Nikai faction team, and Komeito.

There have recently been some interesting developments in Japan’s political landscape which may have serious influence on Prime Minister Suga’s upcoming election for party presidency. First, former Prime Minister Shinzo Abe has become healthy again thanks to new medicine and has been active in political activities; he has assumed the chief advisory position of the LDP Constitution Revision Committee.  Former Prime Minister Abe seems to have an option of officially returning to the powerful Seiwakai faction to become a kingmaker or the king again. He is still relatively young at 66 years old and Seiwakai seems to lack an upcoming candidate to succeed Prime Minister Suga, creating an opening for former Prime Minister Abe. Incidentally, at this particular time, former Prime Minister Abe has no option but to support Prime Minister Suga together with Deputy Prime Minister Aso to maintain party unity, when the LDP is facing the Lower House election amid the COVID-19 crisis, the challenge of hosting the Summer Olympics and Paralympics, and the triple election loss disaster on April 25.

Secondly, when Prime Minister Suga was Chief Cabinet Secretary during the Abe administration, he had a close relationship with Secretary-General Toshihiro Nikai through his right-hand men, Acting Secretary-General Motoo Hayashi and Diet Affairs Committee Chair Hiroshi Moriyama. However, even though Prime Minister Suga had a major victory in the party presidential election with the support of Secretary-General Nikai, relations between Prime Minister Suga and Secretary-General Nikai have cooled down over Prime Minister Suga’s decision to stop the “Go to Travel” campaign. The campaign was designed to benefit Secretary-General Nikai’s political support base, the sightseeing industry, to curb increases in COVID-19 cases. Moreover, relations between Prime Minister Suga and former Prime Minister Abe have become closer over Prime Minister Suga’s efforts to build a strong relationship with the United States. As the U.S.-Japan alliance begins to look like an anti-China coalition, Secretary-General Nikai, who is known to be a pro-China politician, does not feel easy about Prime Minister Suga’s emerging closeness with former Prime Minister Abe and hard stance on China, to say the least.

Thirdly, Secretary-General Nikai, who has seen an erosion in his political influence within the LDP, might leave Prime Minister Suga and decide to support someone else to retain influence. Political observers in Japan think that it was no accident that Secretary-General Nikai said, “canceling the Tokyo Olympics could be an option if the coronavirus spreads further” and “I don’t know what the Olympics would be for, if the games help the virus to spread.” Prime Minister Suga took notice of Secretary-General Nikai’s sniping by saying, “the government’s stance on preparing to hold the games safely has not been changed.” Wild speculation is that Tokyo Governor Yuriko Koike declares cancellation of the Olympics and Paralympics. While it would be a terribly populist and even risky move for the Tokyo Governor to do so, she might gamble as her political base, the Tokyoites First Party, desperately needs a boost for the Tokyo Assembly elections scheduled to take place on July 4. Therefore, Secretary-General Nikai, who has worked with Governor Koike, might team up with Governor Koike to check Prime Minister Suga, who does not get along with Governor Koike at all.

Fourthly, there is currently no strong competitor to Prime Minister Suga for the party presidency. As mentioned earlier, former Prime Minister Abe, who may have an aspiration to come back for the third time, will continue to support Prime Minister Suga with Deputy Prime Minister Aso to avoid confusion within the party heading into the Lower House election, amid difficulty handling the COVID-19 crisis and the Tokyo Olympics and Paralympics. Former Policy Research Council Chair Fumio Kishida was badly damaged as Hidenori Nishita, the LDP candidate, whom Mr. Kishida backed as President of LDP Hiroshima, lost in the recent Upper House by-election. As a matter of fact, there is speculation that former Defense Minister Yoshimasa Hayashi might take over the head of the Kishida faction in the near future. Likewise, former Chief Cabinet Secretary Shigeru Ishiba has also lost momentum. He stepped down as head of his faction last October following his last-place finish in the party presidential election. His standing within the party has been greatly reduced.

Lastly, Komeito, the coalition partner for LDP, has been in disarray since Mr. Kiyohiko Toyama, a former Lower House member, resigned in January over a visit to an expensive hostess bar in Ginza despite the COVID-19 state of emergency. Mr. Toyama was widely regarded as a possible successor to Natsuo Yamaguchi as party president. Moreover, Deputy Chairman of Soka Gakkai, Hiroshi Sato, who was a counterpart for Prime Minister Suga, unexpectedly retired in February most likely taking responsibility for Toyama’s actions. The powerful Women Division within Soka Gakkai, the Buddhist Support base for Komeito, was angry with irresponsible actions by Komeito politicians. Incidentally, Soka Gakkai’s election campaign power is on the decline due to aging membership. The goal for the Lower House snap election for Komeito is 8 million votes but the party received less than 7 million in the previous Lower House election.

A consensus among political observers in Japan at this time is that Prime Minister Suga will continue chugging along to be re-elected party president and continue as Prime Minister of Japan. Of course, assumptions are that new COVID-19 cases will be prevented from exploding, the Summer Olympics and Paralympics will be safely held without disaster, and the LDP will maintain a united front going into a snap Lower House election. Needless to say, these are all uncertain assumptions.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email