Chairman's Message

Chairman’s Message: Trump’s trip to Asia and fundamentals to consider in a high stakes environment

President Trump in Corpus Christi, Texas, August 29, 2017. Image source: Official White House Photo by Andrea Hanks.

President Trump leaves this weekend for his first trip to Asia, with an initial stop in Japan. His top national security cabinet officers Jim Mattis and Rex Tillerson have had several productive visits already, so the President has a good foundation on which to build. There is a full U.S.-Japan security, economic, and diplomatic agenda for the President and Prime Minister Abe.

Dealing with North Korea is at the top of the agenda both in Japan and at subsequent stops in South Korea and China. Although the last North Korean missile and nuclear weapon tests occurred in September, new tests might take place during the upcoming visit. The most dangerous provocation that North Korea has threatened is a nuclear missile test firing into the Pacific Ocean.

The President and his team need to keep a few fundamentals in mind during the visit. Keeping our alliances with Japan and South Korea strong for the long term is as important as handling any current crisis with North Korea. This means frequent and close consultation with those countries, not unilateral American decisions followed by notification of the allies. So far, the diplomatic and economic measures against the DPRK have been developed and implemented in full consultation and coordination.

If North Korea does in fact launch a nuclear missile into the Pacific, the reaction should be a massive American and South Korean air and missile strike against all known DPRK nuclear test facilities and missile launching and support facilities. The strike should be launched from South Korean and Japanese bases, as well as U.S. ships and bases in the United States. Now is the time to consult with Japan and South Korea about this possibility as well as responses to other potential DPRK provocations. To launch a retaliatory strike of such scope, all three countries will need to increase their military readiness in case of North Korean retaliation and take steps to provide civil defense in South Korea and Japan to protect their citizens and the tens of thousands of Americans who live in both countries.

However, North Korea should not be the only security issue on the U.S.-Japan agenda during the President’s visit. The President needs to reconfirm that the American nuclear guarantee protects Japan in the case of a North Korean nuclear attack, and that Article IV of the 1960 Treaty of Mutual Cooperation and Security applies to the Senkaku Islands in case of aggression by China. For his part, Prime Minister Abe needs to reconfirm that under the new interpretation of collective self defense, Japanese forces have the authority to assist the United States and its military forces in certain contingencies such as a North Korean attack.

The South China Sea has been quiet recently, without aggressive Chinese moves. Beyond communiques calling for peace, the two leaders and their staffs need to discuss a carefully coordinated diplomatic, economic, and military program to support Vietnam, Malaysia, and the Philippines, and synchronized deployments of U.S. and Japanese forces to the region for exercises to assert the international character of the sea and air space.

The President and the Prime Minister need to articulate their vision for the Asia Pacific region.

The economic relationship between the United States and Japan is under tension due to an American desire to lessen its bilateral trade deficit with Japan and a Japanese determination to update multilateral trade practices in the Asia Pacific region by pursuing a Trans-Pacific Partnership after the U.S. withdrawal that would including the 11 remaining countries, in part to offset Chinese economic influence in the region. The bureaucracies in both countries need a signal from the two leaders that they understand each other’s objectives and will approve plans that work towards both goals.

Perhaps most important, the President and the Prime Minister need to articulate their vision for the Asia Pacific region. President Xi provided his concept at the recently concluded party congress, and it is one that over time places an authoritarian China at the center of Asian affairs. Most other Asian countries find that vision more frightening than reassuring, and they look to the United States and Japan for a better alternative. The two most powerful democracies in the region need to describe a future for the Indo-Pacific region that is secure, peaceful, prosperous, and free.

More Posts

Chairman’s Message: The 2+2 meeting that did not happen

In this Chairman’s Message, Admiral Dennis Blair discusses the postponed “2+2” meeting between the U.S. Secretaries of State and Defense and Japan’s Ministers of Foreign Affairs and Defense, and explains that the postponement does not reflect any deterioration of U.S.-Japan relations.

Chairman’s Message: Revising the Japanese Constitution

An amendment to Japan’s constitution to provide a legal basis for the SDF is long overdue. Yet, before this happens, the Government of Japan must clarify civil-military relations, and the roles and missions of the three SDF services need to be reassessed.

Chairman’s Message: The future of the U.S.-Japan alliance

In this edition of the Chairman’s Message, Admiral Dennis Blair looks back on forty years of experience with U.S.-Japan relations and explains why, with this long and deep perspective on the Alliance, he can say without qualification that it is the strongest it ever has been — and how to continue to grow the relationship into the future.

About the expert

Blair.Headshot square

Adm. Dennis C. Blair is Chairman of the Board and Distinguished Senior Fellow (Non-Resident) of Sasakawa USA, and additionally led the Foundation as CEO from 2014 to February 2017. He is a renowned expert on Asia Pacific policy and issues, having served as Director of National Intelligence and Commander in Chief of the U.S. Pacific Command. Read his Chairman's Message column here or his other publications and analysis here